Is it fair to blame the onions?

Sep 18, 2020

News Stories on Salmonella Outbreaks Might not Tell the Whole Story

Across the country, Canadians are rightly throwing out onions possibly contaminated with Salmonella as the outbreak rages on with almost 500 cases and 66 hospitalizations. The common symptoms of the illness include diarrhea, vomiting, nausea, headache and fever which are at best quite unpleasant, but especially for vulnerable individuals and people with other health complications, are incredibly dangerous. But is it really the fault of onions or is something larger at play?

Salmonella, like other common food-poisoning pathogens E.coli and Campylobacter, are due to fecal residue which in this case is likely from manure used from farmed animals. They are intestinal bugs and with the intensive conditions factory farming brings, becoming more and more normalized to be in our food products. We can look back at the 2010 Salmonella outbreak that caused the United States to recall 550 million eggs and sickened 1,470 people. When FDA officials examined the relevant farms, they were disgusted to discover evidence of manure, along with rodents, flies, cats, and birds in facilities that collectively had 7.7 million caged hens.

And yet, the problem continues. There has been a six fold increase in food poisoning over the last few decades with meat and animal products being the most common cause. It’s a startling figure, but makes sense when you start to look at the contamination statistics where there’s fecal matter in about two thirds of American beef and greater than 80% fecal contamination in poultry

This indicates that this Salmonella outbreak won’t be the last. Yet foodborne illness from fecal bacteria shouldn’t be a reality that we consent to or normalize. Back in the 1930s, Winston Churchill was already envisioning another way. He predicted that in 50 years “[w]e shall escape the absurdity of growing a whole chicken in order to eat the breast or wing, by growing these parts separately under a suitable medium.”

Today, that exact solution is coming to light all over the world. ‘Clean meat’, the popular term for meat that is grown in a lab, is becoming a reality. It made its debut on the world stage in 2013 when Mark Post, a Dutch tissue engineer, ate the first lab-grown burger in an event that was televised across the world. The typical way to create meat this way is by using starting cells, and with the help of a growth serum, having them multiply until they are turned into the desired combination of muscle and fat.

Many different sectors are turning towards this production method in hopes that it will solve key world issues. For foodborne illness, producing meat that doesn’t have intestines ensures there’s no risk of these intestinal bugs. Beyond that, the massive inputs of environmental resources of meat take a disproportionate toll, with 83% of farmland used in agriculture to produce just 13% of the calories, and similar disparities among greenhouse gas emissions and water use. It is just extremely inefficient to grow tons of food that is fed to animals for months and years before they are slaughtered for meat. Finally, what does it say about our morality as a species when 80 billion animals a year are slaughtered?

We have been given ample chances to learn our lessons on food safety. We may all be one meal away from the next devastating pandemic unless we realize the cost of our choices.

By Opinion by: PJ Nyman, Corporate Engagement Manager, Mercy For Animals Canada 08 Feb, 2024
This blog post is brought to you by friends of Reimagine Agriculture, Mercy For Animals.
By Aleisha Pannozzo 26 Oct, 2023
Header Image Source: Antoine Maillard, New York Times By: Aleisha Pannozzo
By Nicole Gavigan 14 Jul, 2023
By Nicole Gavigan, Education Specialist at Reimagine Agriculture
By Nicole Gavigan 11 Jul, 2023
By Nicole Gavigan, Education Specialist at Reimagine Agriculture
By Lydia Lavis 23 Jun, 2023
By Lydia Lavis, Education Specialist at Reimagine Agriculture
By Nicole Gavigan 13 Jun, 2023
A lot has changed in the last 80 years
By Lydia Lavis 07 Jun, 2023
By: Lydia Lavis, Education Specialist at Reimagine Agriculture
23 Jun, 2022
An Interview with Linda Fox from the Canadian Food Innovation Network
By Lucas Porter 26 May, 2022
An Op-ed from our Executive Director
26 May, 2022
Is plant-based the same as vegan? Is a plant-based diet healthy?
More Posts
Share by: